[quote author=Gomer link=topic=5180.msg66508#msg66508 date=1228069852] We actually talked about a subcommittee to decide, but went with the idea of giving the membership some say since it is their coral [/quote] Just was brainstorming (I do this when I procrastinate from work related things ) about the whole Xtreme thing. How about letting ALL members get some say in it? As it stands now the only votes that really count are the yes ones, and a few times I've not voted on something because I was going to vote no. But no votes don't mean anything, as it stands now if you have 100 people say no, and only 10 say yes it still gets counted as an Xtreme coral. Now I don't know if this was done purposefully this way, or not, but if I might toss in a WIBGI suggestion.... How about making the criteria for an X-treme coral be that there are 10 MORE yes votes than no votes. So if 5 people vote no, then at least 15 need to vote yes. I mean lets be honest there are corals out there that some people just think are more extreme than others, a new reefer might think anything non-brown is extreme, and since you are trying to encourage people to vote when polls pop up, you really are sending the message only vote if you want this coral moved. To further bounce ideas off this too, make sure polls allow people to change their vote too, so corals can lose their Xtreme status, it'd be neat if you can program this feature in but being as I know nothing about programming don't know how easy/hard/feasible that could be (not requesting it either... just brainstorming I said ) that way Bryan or whatever mod with his eye on the board doesn't need to keep an eye on threads.