Well according to my records, which I did forward to Norman quite a while ago, the oldest ones in
Leng Sy (Mr. Ugly) on 2/27/06 (no further generations)
Then a few days later the Pavona, Elkhorn Monti, and Efflo Ugliest went out which put out a couple generations, I think the Elkhorn did 4(?) although I don't have that recorded, I'm just going by my foggy memory.
As to the not seeing many go on, one reason why I asked people post in a central thread that something went on, and to post NEW messages to the existing thread rather than editing it (which doesn't bump). Some of it is cut and run I'm sure, although a lot of it is die off I'm sure, there were a handful of members getting a lions share of the "free corals" and if they had a tank meltdown that would do it. Although some of the reasons I wanted out had to do more with the lack of propagation on some of the "faster growing" and not seeing much return and not wanting to get personally involved (i.e. getting pissed off and telling people "hey don't you think you should give back a little more than ask?")