High Tide Aquatics

Eight's 170 gallon in wall LeeMar

It's now been a month and a half since I have had my "one-way waterchange quarantine/frag tank setup" in place. There was some discussion a couple of pages ago on the pros/cons of setting up the system this way and I said that I would let the system run for several weeks and then comment back on how it's going. Here are my thoughts so far.

The frag tank is filled mostly with LPS and some SPS. I haven't lost anything and most pieces seem to be growing well, although I don't have anything really delicate in there. Some corals, such as the golden eye watermelon and Miami Hurricane frags are growing exceptionally well.

Other than the waterchanging system, a heater, powerheads and lights, there isn't any hardware on the tank. No reactor, no topoff, no skimmer, no carbon, no GFO, etc.

I currently change about 4 gallons a day out of my display tank into the frag tank. This is equivalent to about a 10% waterchange every day on the frag tank.

Salinity does tend to drift up over time since I do not have a freshwater topoff system on the tank. I estimate that it goes up 0.001 each week. (So it goes from 1.025 to 1.026 each week if I don't do anything to it.) To combat this, I simply pour straight RODI water into the tank a couple of times a week to dilute it back down to 1.025. This isn't ideal, but it's pretty easy and doesn't seem to cause too much stress. Other parameters (KH, etc.) experience slight fluctuation (probably similar to/due to the salinity drift).

The best thing about this setup is that it does work as designed... it is a full time quarantine system separate from my main display. I purchased a metallic green pavona coral from Dolphin a few weeks ago that was covered in flatworms... I dipped it hard and didn't hesitate about putting it into the QT system which was very comforting. Other than the water topoff, it's been maintenance free and hasn't caused me any problems.

That said, I have debated about going to a more traditionally plumbed frag tank. The primary reasons I have reconsidered are:

1) There's no surface skimmer on this setup, so I get that nasty oily slick on the surface. Yuck!

2) Despite the fact that things have done well, I do worry that sometimes this frag tank is not as stable/consistent as my display. This may be more of a psychological neurosis rather than a material problem, but it still bugs me.

3) I tend to be aggressive on the waterchange percent (10% of the frag tank volume/day which is equivalent to about 2% of my main display volume/day) because I don't want the frag tank water quality to suffer. Remains to be seen if I can drop this waterchange percent down lower without any waste buildup. Aggressive waterchanging costs money in salt and RO water.

I will keep this setup running like this for a few more months. Overtime I may gain more confidence in the system which will tip the pros decisively over the cons... right now though, I'm kinda 50/50 about whether or not as a whole this is better than a standard frag tank setup.
 
Thanks guys. :) I think the proof of a good tank is really having consistent, long term success... something that others have done much better than me... trying though!
 
Tank is hitting its stride now. I've got Alk nailed at 11dkh and my PH has been quite solid between 8.0 and 8.2. Everything has been doing pretty well.

Time for some updated photos.

Full tank:

561574092_mmN4E-L.jpg


Rainbow acans and others in my frag tank:

560689769_cUfuF-L.jpg


Awesome plate coral I got from Neptune:

552546755_qR7pS-L.jpg


Orange aussie hammer coral... I've been on a rare hammer, torch, frogspawn binge...

561574142_5kbqH-L.jpg


Electric blue aussie hammer:

561574128_vfuNT-L.jpg


Archohelia Rediviva:

561574115_dS6mV-L.jpg


Sad I can't make it to BAYMAC this weekend...
 
nice looking stuff Eight, I cant wait to start me 180 tank tread, I have 6 tanks running but they are a little tanks waiting for the mother ship to land. Soon and week or two and it gets wet.

jeremy
 
Wow, nice setup!
I have a 72 bowfront and will be upgrading in the near future to a 300gal.
I love to see how you have your auto water change setup if you don't mind. :bigsmile:
 
Jason:

Got lost in your tank thread and can't seem to find the link of the place you bought the PVC manifold, would you send it tome please?

Thx
 
Well, I'm leaving for Amsterdam tomorrow, so here's an update before I go. Whenever I go on vacation, I always have something go wrong. So I figure if I take photos I'll at least have *something* to remember it by. :p (This time around, though I feel better prepared than usual. Knock on wood.)

Full tank shot:

643696405_vPpVG-M.jpg


Left side:

643696544_YnKY7-M.jpg


Right side:

643696475_TuQYP-M.jpg


Anemone island in the middle:

643696606_nGMMp-M.jpg


Highlighters acan. Shot under actinics and then white balanced:

643696176_Q2iPZ-M.jpg


Another rainbow acan:

643696232_4gEQq-M.jpg


Orange hammer, Blue wall frogspawn, Blue hammer, Monitpora Undata, Green eyed favia, Christmas favia:

643696665_urJ9m-M.jpg


Unidentified coral... ? Not sure what it is...

643696276_q8CMd-M.jpg


Electric green pavona:

643696386_r7GpC-M.jpg


Fiery acan, one of my current favorites:

643696203_8XgZ8-M.jpg


Gold and green cloves. I grew these from a single head.

643696313_8Uqgw-M.jpg
 
what could go wrong? - good luck hope you got a good person watching your tank. you don't need a skimmer, just one more thing that can fail : )
 
Back
Top