So I just found a one plug in my cabinet with a stem, and measured the stem (~9mm diameter).
Ideally, we'd want to identify early (here in this thread) the sizes of plugs we actually want. I can then pre-make a handful of molds for the different sizes. To keep things simple, it's probably best to pick 2 or 3 sizes/shapes that we want. For example:
3/4" diameter top circle, with 3/8" stem that is 3/4" long
1" diameter top circle, with 3/8" stem that is 3/4" long
1.25" disc with no stem
.... or something like that.